The NOS (Dutch Broadcasting Organisation) has the following story. On television they show a big smiling Maxime Verhagen, former minister of Foreign Affairs (CDA) now appointed as special representative to get as many orders on the JSF program as possible for Dutch industry. Of course he is very positive but he also exaggerates enormously about the possible values. Some of the “facts” of this broadcast:
- 27 Dutch companies have made it to generate work from the JSF program (0:22)
- Fokker: for 40 JSF per year they build parts (0:26)
- Aeronamic has an order ( worth € 220 milj) work for at least 50 people (0:32)
- There will be more work, € 8 to € 9 billion with hundreds of jobs. (0:36)
- Maxime Verhagen: After building there also will come future contracts for the maintenance work also worth € 10 to € 20 billion
I would like to ask Mr. Verhagen some key questions: On what grounds where those prognoses based? These where the figures based on the business case of the Dutch Air Force buying 85 JSF not 37. But are those still appropriate?
Another quote of mr Verhagen: If you don’t invest.. you won’t receive anything. (0:45)
Can we expect the US to give us the same amount of orders? What about some non-partner-nations willing to acquire the JSF with demands of large production participation? Like Japan, South-Korea and Israel? Howe come they didn’t invest a billion euro’s in this program and still receive orders far more wort than ours? While they even order in the same amount of aircraft (around 40 each?) And what about those figures and orders we see sometimes in the Dutch News. Stories about new orders, signature signing of orders. All celebrated but not always clear if it’s a new one… or one already arranged long time ago… but celebrated as a new victory (for marketing purposes of course),
Repeating old contracts and framework agreements with each small successor agreement, if re-extracted billions turnover ……….
The annual PV F16 allow hitherto SALES tens of millions to the recognition of the “JSF Business Case” (which is not MARGIN = value) show per year.
Super nice of course …….
But Aeronamic works for Airbus; and work would have been if we DO NOT buy the JSF; simply because they are innovative.
Fokker / STORK
THE HAGUE – Stork Fokker’s flaperons, movable flaps on the wings, producing for American combat unit JSF. For this purpose, Tuesday (October 6) signed a contract with aircraft manufacturer Lockheed Martin.
(and even at least 4 times, and so on)
Aeronamic (part of the work is outsourced to Romanian branch)
November 17, 2010
Aeronamic has a contract for the supply of the so-called Air Management System for Turbomachinery energy on board the aircraft.
Honeywell, a company that for years Aeronamic Siezen recent works, signed an agreement for the construction of Terminal Power Management Systems (PTMs) for half of the total number of building F-35’s. “The system regulates the energy system aboard the new American fighter. It is an order of 500 to 600 million and provides 50 to 60 of our people for thirty years working on “The deal goes through, but under one condition., The Dutch government should proceed to purchase the F-35. “How many devices they buy does not matter. If only they buy. “
Production of 220 million and 50 men work.
How often do we have to repeat this??
I would like to recommend an article by Krijn Schramada of the revealing Follow The Money website: JSF industry consider themselves rich with turnover.